Different Models of Union
[2 ]
In Search of A Better Union
Published on November 22, 2023
Gen. Sumlut Gun Maw of the Kachin Independence Army (KIA) made a comment in a recent BBC interview that in the future there would exist not the “Union of Burma/Myanmar”. There could be a union but not “pyi-daung-su-myan-mar-naing-an”. [1]
Looking for a political arrangement of the future of the country does not have to be limited by the dichotomy of staying-under-the-centralized-union vs secession. The following are some different models of unions in the world today.
Different Models of Union
The Russian Federation
Commonwealth Realms
European Union
Swiss Confederation
United States
United Kingdom
Union of Burma/Myanmar
The Russian Federation
The Russian Federation is the official name of Russia. It is a federation of 86 republics, provinces, territories, and districts. The government in Moscow controls all of these entities.
The Russian Federation is the largest country in the world, covering 6.6 million square miles. It stretches across 11 time zones and is 6,000 miles in length. The population is around 141.7 million, with over 100 ethnic groups.
The Russian Federation has a highly centralized, authoritarian political system. The president is the executive head of state and the supreme commander-in-chief of the Russian Armed Forces. The bicameral Federal Assembly has a directly elected lower house and an appointed upper house.
The Russian Federation is made up of 89 constituent units, which are divided into six categories:
Republics, Territories, Regions, Autonomous areas, Autonomous region, Federal cities.
Commonwealth Realms
Commonwealth realms are sovereign states that are part of the Commonwealth of Nations. They have the British monarch as their head of state. The monarch's role is mostly symbolic, as the countries have their own governments.
As of 2023, there are 15 Commonwealth realms:
Antigua and Barbuda
Australia
The Bahamas
Barbados
Belize
Canada
Grenada
Jamaica
New Zealand
Papua New Guinea
Saint Kitts and Nevis
Saint Lucia
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
The Solomon Islands
Tuvalu
Commonwealth realms include the United Kingdom and many of its former colonies or territories. They are unique in the history of constitutional law because of their shared Sovereign, voluntary nature, and geographical spread.
[T]he nations were considered "equal in status ... though united by a common allegiance to the Crown".
[KI’s Commentary: Future of Burma can be designed so that sovereign nations are equal in status though united by a common allegiance to the Union for defense and economic cooperation]
European Union
The European Union (EU) is a political and economic union of 27 European countries. The EU was created in 1993 to oversee the economic and political integration of these countries. The EU has a total area of 1.6 square miles and an estimated population of over 448 million.
The EU promotes democratic values and is a powerful trade bloc. Some benefits of EU membership include:
Growing internal market and domestic demand
Free movement of labor, goods, services, and capital
Free access to 450 million consumers
The EU's capital is Brussels. Other cities that host major EU institutions include:
Luxembourg: Judicial and second seats
Strasbourg: Parliament's main seat
The EU has one of the world's worst environmental footprints per capita.
Switzerland
Switzerland's official name is Swiss Confederation, or Schweizerische Eidgenossenschaft in German. Switzerland is one of the oldest nations in Europe.
Switzerland is a federal state with three levels of governance:
Confederation: The central state
Cantons: The 26 federal states
Communes: The 2,352 communes
Each level has its own legislature and executive. The Federal Assembly (Parliament) has two chambers that debate constitutional amendments and federal legislation.
Switzerland has been a federal state since 1848. The country's federalism is a bottom-up system where the cantons have a lot of autonomy. The Federal Constitution limits their sovereignty.
United states
The United States has a federalist system of government. This system is based on the Constitution, which divides power between the federal government and the state governments. The Constitution gives certain powers to the federal government, while other powers are reserved for the states.
The federalist system has been a point of contention since the Articles of Confederation. Since the country's founding, power has shifted from the states to the national government.
The United States federal system has four components:
State sovereignty
Constitutional limitations on state power
Federal government powers
Relationship between the federal government and the states
The federal government is made up of three branches: Legislative, Executive, Judicial.
The Constitution gives the following powers to the federal government: Congress, President, Federal courts.
The 10th Amendment limits the powers of the federal government. It states that powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution are reserved for the states or the people.
The federal government's purpose is to:
Establish justice
Ensure domestic tranquility
Provide for the common defense
Promote the general welfare
Secure the blessings of liberty
Some functions of the federal government include:
Making money
Declaring war
Managing foreign relations
Overseeing trade between states and other countries
United Kingdom
The United Kingdom (UK) is a unitary state with asymmetric decentralization. The UK is made up of four countries: England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. These countries have different economies, histories, and nationalities.
The UK has a central UK parliament and a prime minister who leads the government. The UK also has devolved governments in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. These devolved governments operate under authority delegated by the UK Parliament. The devolved governments include:
Scottish Government
Welsh Government
Northern Ireland Executive
The UK has some federal features. The devolved territories are similar to the "states" of a federal constitution. The UK has no formal written constitution or constitutional division of power.
The UK's government is led by the Prime Minister and the Head of State is the King. The Prime Minister is responsible for all policy and decisions. The Prime Minister also appoints members of the government and oversees the operation of the Civil Service and government agencies.
Union of Burma/Myanmar
Myanmar, also known as Burma, has a unitary assembly-independent republic. The country's political system has gone through many changes since it gained independence from British colonial rule in 1948:
1948–1962: The Union of Burma began as a parliamentary democracy.
1962–1974: Direct military rule.
1974–1988: Constitutional dictatorship. The country was ruled as a one-party state with the Burma Socialist Programme Party (BSPP) as the only legal political party.
2011: The military junta was dissolved and a civilian government was installed.
2021: The military took over the government in a coup.
The country's 2008 constitution establishes it as a unitary assembly-independent republic. The president is elected by parliament and is responsible for:
Appointing the cabinet
Nominating judges
Leading the armed forces
Overseeing government tasks
The Pyidaungsu Hluttaw is the country's bicameral parliament. It has 664 members, including:
House of Representatives: 440 seats
House of Nationalities: 224 seats
Finally, the following except from Studies of International Law on the foundation moment gives some light to the states of Burma.
"The basic social model that was used to bring peace to Europe was a very simple model. In order to live together in peace, states would live separately, each of them being sovereign on its own territory and equal to one another."
[Prof. Pierre d'Argent - UCL]3
The above article was generated by the assistant of Google Generative AI Search Lab and verified by Saw Lahkbaw.
Reference:
[1] https://youtu.be/BLMkV3WHPpQ?si=XMQeBqJXs3gnpXfI
[2] https://50shadesoffederalism.com/case-studies/switzerland-2017-re-birth-federalism/
[3] https://youtu.be/1SbdlteP9Qk?si=HKS3Q4e1N1H3QQVI